In recent years, the NFL has shifted its perspective on the value of safeties, signaling a significant change in how teams approach this position. Once considered crucial playmakers, safeties are now trending toward becoming the defensive equivalent of running backs—players whose market value has significantly decreased. Let’s explore why the league’s view on safeties has evolved and what it means for the future.
“There’s so much opportunity to overcome physical talent with high level intellect and intangibles. So you don’t have to overspend to get production,” one NFL personnel executive told CBS Sports. “You can draft these guys Day 3 or put low free-agency resources into them and get production back if they are smart
The Changing Landscape in the NFL
Teams are increasingly making tough decisions regarding their safety positions. High-priced safeties are no longer guaranteed lucrative contracts. Instead, teams are opting to save money by parting ways with established players.
The Denver Broncos released four-time All-Pro safety Justin Simmons, despite his impressive performance. Similarly, the New York Giants let go of 24-year-old safety Xavier McKinney, who had 11 passes defensed last season. Other teams, including the Seahawks, Bills, and Jaguars, have also made similar moves.
Across the league, more than $103 million in cash salary has been saved in 2024 by trimming safety contracts, surpassing the savings from cornerback contracts by nearly $40 million.
Teams recognize that safeties can overcome physical limitations with high-level intellect and intangibles. Smart drafting and strategic use of free-agency resources can yield productive results without overspending.
Safeties’ roles are scheme-dependent. While some fit perfectly within certain defensive systems, others may struggle.
Exceptions to the Rule
Worthwhile Investments: Safeties like Derwin James, Antoine Winfield Jr., and future prospect Kyle Hamilton remain worth paying for. Their versatility and impact justify their contracts.
Game-Changing Safeties: If safety can cover tight ends, excel in run defense, force turnovers, and maintain solid coverage, they will command a hefty salary. However, such all-around talents are rare.
In summary, the NFL’s evolving stance on safeties reflects a pragmatic approach—prioritizing cost-effectiveness and adaptability. While some safeties continue to shine, the league as a whole is redefining the position’s worth in today’s game.
Read More- Tyrann Mathieu and the New Orleans Saints: A Contract Rework in the Works
